Debate Motion Analysis

MOTION : TH SHOULD BAN CIGARETTES FROM SOCIETY.

Opening Government :
- Cigarettes is bad for our health.
- Cigarettes don't have good value for us.
- Smoking is not a solution for stress, the solution is strengthening our bond with God.

Opening Opposition :
- Some people smoke when they're stressed.
- People can smoke because it's their right and it's all about how the society perceives that smoking is a symbol for maturity and masculinity.
- We shouldn't ban smoking because the smokers can smoke in a private room.
- If we ban cigarettes, all the people who work in a cigarettes factory will be unemployed.

Closing Government :
The chemical materials from the cigarettes bring a bad impact for our health. Cigarettes is not a solution for stress. If we're stressed, we can take the medicine that is recommended by doctors or we can go to psychologist.

Closing Opposition :
We shouldn't ban cigarettes from the society because there are a lot of people that work in a cigarette factory. If we ban cigarettes, there will be so many unemployed people.

Winner : Opposition Team, because they made good arguments. In my opinion, the Government Team is way too repetitive with their arguments. Another point why i chose Opposition Team is because i believe smoking is a rights as long as they are legal and they are smoking in a private room.

MOTION : TH SHOULD BAN PORNOGRAPHY
Opening Government :
We should ban all the pornography because it's not good for our health, it will causes curiosity and then it makes us want to try it.

Opening Opposition :
We shouldn't ban all the pornography because it's good for our health.

Closing Government :
We should ban all the pornography because pornography addiction is more hazardous than drug and alcohol addiction.

Closing Opposition :
We shouldn't ban pornography because there are a lot of people that work in that industry.

Winner : Government Team because porn is actually bad for our mental. Porn is also decreasing our intelligence.

MOTION : THE REALITY SHOWS BRING HARMS.

Opening Government :
If children sees reality show, the children will follow all the action in that show despite reality show bring a negative effect to the children itself.

Opening Opposition :
We may learn important information and reality show might be good for discussing new topics.

Opening Government :
Reality shows generally are fake, made-up, scripted, and all the editing is "flavored" with dramas.

Closing Opposition :
Reality shows have a plenty of knowledges and educational contents. Besides that, reality shows has an entertaining purposes.

Closing Government :
Not all the children is guarded by parents in home, so reality shows can be dangerous for them.

Winner : Government Team, because i think reality shows in Indonesia doesn't have educational content. They tends to catch up the TV rating, so reality shows contents are all fake, scripted, and has a lot of drama.